Skeptical birds debunk "Artificial Flight"

By Cory Doctorow at 10:52 am Thursday, Feb 18

Dresden Codak's "Artificial Flight and Other Myths (a reasoned examination of A.F. by top birds)" is a superb, spot-on critique of artificial intelligence skeptics (like, ahem, me), comparing the our arguments against the emergence of "real AI" to the arguments a bird might make against "real" artificial flight. I love being made to re-examine my own convictions while laughing my ass off:

We can start with a loose definition of flight. While no two bird scientists or philosophers can agree on the specifics, there is still a common, intuitive understanding of what true flight is: powered, feathered locomotion through the air through the use of flapping wings. While other flight-like phenomena exist in nature (via bats and insects), no bird with even a reasonable education would consider these creatures true fliers, as they lack one or more key elements. And, while some birds are unfortunately born handicapped (penguins, ostriches, etc.), they still possess the (albeit undeveloped) gene for flight, and it is indeed flight that defines the modern bird.

This is flight in the natural world, the product of millions of years of evolution, and not a phenomenon easily replicated. Current A.F. is limited to unpowered gliding; a technical marvel, but nowhere near the sophistication of a bird. Gliding simplifies our lives, and no bird (including myself) would discourage advancing this field, but it is a far cry from synthesizing the millions of cells within the wing alone to achieve Strong A.F. Strong A.F., as it is defined by researchers, is any artificial flier that is capable of passing the Tern Test (developed by A.F. pioneer Alan Tern), which involves convincing an average bird that the artificial flier is in fact a flying bird.

Artificial Flight and Other Myths (a reasoned examination of A.F. by top birds) (via Futurismic)

(Image: Anna's Hummingbird in Flight, a Creative Commons Attribution photo from Noël Zia Lee's photostream)