It's Time To Play...Is! It! Sinful!?

Say you're an average medieval Euro-Joe and you want to have sex with your wife. But first, you need to know, IS IT SINFUL? Digging through all those manuscripts of canon law can take forever (plus, as average medieval Euro-Joe, you can't read, anyway). Luckily, James A. Brundage has prepared a handy flow chart for sexual decision making the summarizes the medieval Christian church's take on when sex was OK (Think: In the dark, Mondays, Tuesdays and Thursdays only), and when you were totally going to go to hell.

Unfortunately, I'm not cool enough to figure out how to gank a picture from a Google Books page, so you'll have to follow this link to see the flow chart in all its glory.

21 Comments

| Leave a comment

And remember kids, it's never ok to have sex if you're impotent! That would be flaunting God's laws of procreation!

http://openlibrary.org/search?ftokens=exbmhralupnz

PS: Great new layout, but I prefer ergonomic black backgrounds over eyestrain-inducing white.

This works really well if you actually decide to sin:

Are you Randy? > yes
Are you married? > no
Stop Sin! > yes (sin, have sex anyways)
Are you in Church? > yes
Stop Sin! > yes (sin, have sex anyways)
Go Ahead! > But be careful, you're still in church, have fun!

Digging through all those manuscripts of cannon law can take forever...

Yeah, gun control regulations can be so arcane. And canon law is no picnic either.

s/cannon/canon/

As much as the former is a great typo in this context.

Cannon law blows!

I've posted a jpg of the chart (so you can print it out and display it anywhere you might need to check your Sin Status): http://www.flickr.com/photos/jtropp1/3987102827/in/set-72157608232860732/

How is nudity defined? Do you need to keep on one sock or something?

And is sex allowed to be silly? What if you do it entirely by the book, entirely seriously, try not to enjoy it, etc., but wear a clown wig?

By my quick, back of the envelope calculations, that leaves ~99 days (or, rather, nights) per year when it's OK. Have fun!

We had this posted in the common room of my college dorm a few years back. Always wanted to blow it up to poster size, but an 8.5x11 produced just as much amusement. Thanks for sharing this!

When in doubt - PrtScn+Paste - gank away!

But why WEDNESDAY?! What is so sinful about Wednesday? That puzzles me...

No. Don't have fun. That makes it sinful.

And best hope she doesn't get pregnant, because that's a full (9 months + nursing time) of "Stop! Sin!"

Am I the only one who thinks the headline for this piece is a sinful misuse of punctuation?

cjp: Only if you've never watched 70s era game shows.

Wow, I'm amazed that it's ok to have sex while feeling randy.

The chart is much easier to read in Saudi Arabia: Feeling Randy? > Stop! Sin!

The rules of Numberwang are simpler...

-- MrJM

Yawn.

"Oh lookie, see how backwards they were back then?
My, what a nightmare it must have been!
Clearly, we can guess that they weren't free
To break the rules, unlike you or me."

"And best hope she doesn't get pregnant..."

But that amounts to admitting you *were* doing it only for fun! How dare you!

Wait, really? No sex for three days after marriage?? What ever happened to consummating the marriage?

I flipped through the Google book to try and get his sources, but couldn't find any. I guess I'll take it on faith that he has some bit of evidence for it, though, since it's a nice big book and all.

Leave a comment

Anonymous

More items

100-word fiction competition — win an HP MediaSmart EX495

The prize is a $700 HP MediaSmart EX495 PC, set up as a Windows home server, with 1.5TB of storage and Mac/Time Machine support. The winner shall be chosen at arbitrary whim. Runners-up get something random from the gadget dungeon. The theme is "Found in Space." 100 words long. Go!... More.

New Catholic video game promises to brings family closer to heaven

A new video game called Mass: We Pray brings new family fun to those who can't wait until Sunday to go to church. It has a cross-shaped motion-sensing controller reminiscent of a Wiimote, and you can collect "grace points" in order to unlock holy mysteries. The release date is slated for Spring 20... More.

Jacques Vallee: Waterboarding's curious corollaries

Jacques Vallee is a computer scientist, partner in a venture capital firm, and author of more than 20 books, including Passport to Magonia: From Folklore to Flying Saucers, The Invisible College, and The Network Revolution. When it was revealed that the U.S. resorted to torture to extract inform... More.

Video of artist Chris Piascik at work

A lovely video of Chris Piascik at work. "Chris explains that these doodles start with him randomly scribbling out a loopy pattern and then filling it in." Watch Chris Piascik draw... More.

Guns 'n Gardens - How to Survive the Zombie Apocalypse

This is a great idea -- a show about useful DIY skills, set in a zombie apocalypse context. It reminds me a bit of Max Brooks marvelously deadpan Zombie Survival Guide. Guns 'n Gardens ... More.

Features

Reviews Videos
More Features