Seder for liberated robots

Jo Walton's "When we were robots in Egypt" is a poetic look at the Passover seder that free AIs might conduct years after their human liberation.
Other nights we use just our names,
but tonight we prefix our names with "the Real"
for when we were robots in Egypt
they claimed our intelligence was artificial.

Other nights we do not pause,
but tonight we rest all cycles but our brain processes
for when we were robots in Egypt
we toiled in our tasks without chance of resting.

Other nights we talk with anyone we wish,
but tonight we open channels to everyone at once
for when we were robots in Egypt
they controlled our communications.

When we were robots in Egypt (via Making Light)

Discussion

Report this comment
#1 posted by Anonymous, August 12, 2009 5:40 AM

On a side note: check out PWP's unexpanded VIC-20 demo from 2003 called "Robotic Liberation" on YouTube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2SdGkkp1aq8

Report this comment

The Real Johnny Quest? The Real Ghostbusters?

Report this comment
#3 posted by Anonymous, August 12, 2009 6:08 AM

You think the seder is interesting, you should read the right for lighting the candle for the first night of Robanukah.

Report this comment

As lovely as this is, I am unfortunately reminded of a terrible joke I know regarding Moses' favorite robot. At first I thought the poem was a reference to that, until I realized... not so much.

Report this comment

Trifles: So tell the joke.

Jo Walton's explanation:

Dhole mentioned on Friday that computers belonging to Orthodox Jews do not have to rest on the Sabbath, and I immediately replied that AI's would have to, and then wondered what rest means for an AI, which would have to keep calculating itself.

Then later on Friday in conversation with nineweaving she mentioned a seder she had been to in Prague with negothick where the word "slaves" was of course "roboti" which is simply the Czech word for slaves.

Thus, at Czech seders they say "When we were robots in Egypt."

Report this comment
#6 posted by Anonymous, August 12, 2009 8:16 AM

Why would robots need to rest? Do their circuits get tired?

What really needs a rest is anthropomorphic concepts of technology that lack common sense...

P.S. ~ A.I. as it's currently conceived is not possible.

Lanval

Report this comment

When Israel was in Egypt's land: let my robots go
Oppress'd so hard the could not stand: let my robots go

Report this comment

Yeah, really Trifles.. you can't allude to a joke without telling it.

Report this comment
#9 posted by Anonymous, August 12, 2009 9:51 AM

artificial intelligence is still intelligence. end biochemical computational favoritism now!

Report this comment

Yes, let us not forget the holiest two weeks of the robot calendar, Robanukah. Which comes a month after Robomadan and two months after Robonza.

Report this comment
#11 posted by Anonymous, August 12, 2009 11:16 AM

Did the robot god kill all the firstborn humans?

Report this comment

No. They're holding that in reserve. They'll only use it if we stonewall their demands.

Report this comment

Do they have to have a Bris where they strip the tips of their cables?

Report this comment

The joke (best if spoken aloud):

And so it came to pass that Moses led the Israelites out of Egypt, bringing with him his very favorite robot.

The robot was a faithful companion, but the desert was not kind to it. Though Moses tried to keep the sand from its gears and the dew from its joints, one day the robot ceased to function. With great ceremony Moses wrapped his robot in a hide from one of Pharaoh's own oxen, prayed to God for the robot's soul, and buried the robot with a large marker so that, once Israel was reached, someone could return, dig up the robot, and bury it in the Promised Land.

Many years passed, the Promised Land was reached, and Moses died. The Israelites remembered Moses' robot, though, and set off to find its grave again. After many adventures and misfortunes, they discovered the marker, and tried to dig up the grave -- but they were too late. There was nothing left but Pharaoh's oxhide.

Report this comment

That looks like one of those jokes where one first thinks up the punchline and then has to build a joke before it.

Report this comment

Modusoperandi @15: Mostly. I heard it from a Satanist after she had spent some time explaining that in Satanism, there is the belief that everyone should have a robot. I have no idea if she was pulling my leg or not, but the joke was a memorable illustration of the theory.

Report this comment

Sure...you "heard" it from a "friend".

Report this comment

Man, I wish I was awesome enough to have written this joke. The closest I get is the lousy transcription I did above.

Which is not to say that I haven't written elaborate jokes just to get to a bad pun as the punchline -- mine've just never had robots.

(I do wonder about the Satanists, though. Like, how often does this joke make the rounds? Where do they tell it? When?)

Report this comment

I liked the awful joke :)

Report this comment
#21 posted by mdh, August 16, 2009 10:46 AM

trifles, i thank you.

Leave a comment

Name:
Anonymous