TV news about man with Fir tree growing in his lung



Here is a TV news story about Artyom Sidorkin, the Russian gentleman who recently had a two-inch live Fir tree removed from his lung where it had taken root. For more on his story, see "The diagnosis? Fir on the lung" in The Guardian. (via Morbid Anatomy)

Discussion

Take a look at this

I bet he had fresh pine-scented breath.

Take a look at this
#2 posted by Anonymous, April 17, 2009 11:18 AM

And this is why your mom told you not to eat watermelon seeds.

Take a look at this
#3 posted by Anonymous, April 17, 2009 11:24 AM

Logger's lung, aka Paul Bunyan's disease.

Take a look at this
#4 posted by Anonymous, April 17, 2009 11:36 AM

How do they know it actually grew there, and that he didn't just inhale a twig like that?

Take a look at this
#5 posted by Anonymous, April 17, 2009 11:36 AM

Nope. He aspirated it, most likely, rather than having had it grow inside of him.

http://tywkiwdbi.blogspot.com/2009/04/russian-man-did-not-aspirate-fir-tree.html

-Darren MacLennan

Take a look at this

Wow! That must have been one of those new, carnivorous, non-UV photosynthesis, coniferous trees. They're all the rage with the kids this season!

/Skeptical cat iz very skeptical

Take a look at this

I dunno - seeds contain a lot of stored energy and nutrients, so I would guess that in theory the thing could grow (at least a little) without any external sources of energy. What I'm more surprised about is the germination, since that usually takes quite specific conditions to kick it off.

Anyway, IANAB (I am not a botanist).

Take a look at this

this has been thoroughly debunked. http://tywkiwdbi.blogspot.com/2009/04/russian-man-did-not-aspirate-fir-tree.html

short answer: what angrypaladin said

Take a look at this

"Igor, if you don't get your butt of that couch you're going to grow root!"

Take a look at this

karengeier @ 4

Look at that, a simple answer. He inhaled it. Occam's razor FTW.

Take a look at this
#11 posted by pjk, April 17, 2009 12:11 PM

Bullshit. First of all, all that talk about a "Russian doctor." I mean, come on, they expect us to believe there are doctors in Russia???

Take a look at this
#12 posted by Anonymous, April 17, 2009 12:47 PM

Is there a small nate or fly buzzing around on the tissue? Is it the newest treatment for Pine Beetles?

Take a look at this
#13 posted by dole, April 17, 2009 1:02 PM

"It will take FIR-ther investigations to get to the ROOT of this mystery."

*cues loser's theme from The Price Is Right*
http://bombombombomwooooo.com
(not a spammer, just thought the link was funny.)

Take a look at this

Yeah, that's the tip of a branch, not a seedling. As noted, it's got no roots. It's also got lots of stiff-looking needles and a thick stem, while a seedling's needles are sparser and softer, with a thin stem.

Pine seedling:
http://www.pbase.com/bkiefer/image/58014705

Take a look at this

Looks like a fir seedling to me. I've no opinion on whether it grew partially while in the lungs, but it's consistent with photos of fir seedlings. A fully-developed fir branch has much longer needles.

#14, the pine seedling photo you linked is not a fir. It looks like a white pine to me, although it's hard to tell. 5 and 8, the blogster you linked claims fir seedlings don't have full inflorescence but doesn't appear to know what the word means (needles are leaves, not flowers). Besides that, fir seedlings do not have particularly sparse needles.

Take a look at this
#17 posted by kate, April 17, 2009 3:09 PM

Urgh. The worst part about the piece of tissue has to be the fly buzzing around and randomly landing on it. Reminds me of that NIN Closer video.

Take a look at this
#18 posted by Anonymous, April 17, 2009 3:16 PM

I for one welcome our seedling overlords.
Baby Bodysnatchers.

Take a look at this

Never saw a root, could be a BBQ cow rib with a single needle cluster stuck in and Boris to play the "Dr."

Take a look at this
#20 posted by Anonymous, April 17, 2009 5:12 PM

Are you guys serious? Do you really not see that it's a mouse pointer and not a fly?

Take a look at this
#21 posted by Anonymous, April 17, 2009 5:20 PM

@ #12, 17

I don't think that's a fly- it's the cursor on his computer. Not all pointers are arrows.

Take a look at this
#22 posted by Anonymous, April 17, 2009 5:34 PM

Sheriff, what kind of fantastic trees have you got growing around here? Big, majestic...
Douglas firs.

Take a look at this

How can somebody inhale such a thing and not remember it?
Oh wait... it's Russia. :D

Take a look at this

In the real Russia, tree inhales you.

Take a look at this
#25 posted by Anonymous, April 17, 2009 9:06 PM

WHAT DID THEY DO WITH THE TREE?
How can we sleep at night without knowing where this predator lurks?

Take a look at this
#26 posted by Anonymous, April 17, 2009 10:35 PM

That's funny, because I developed a bad infection and lung cysts after having a christmas tree in my house for a month.

The doctors concluded it was histoplasmosis caused by a bird's nest in the tree that I must have missed. Okee......I decorated the christmas tree, don't you think I would have known if there was a bird's nest in it?

I wonder if I had some baby trees growing in there. Hahaha. Actually it wasn't so funny at the time, I was coughing up blood at the time.

Doc says my lungs encapsulated the invading infection, leaving me with cysts, which I still have today.

Take a look at this

Check out Boris Vian - L'écume des jours (Froth of the days). Written in the 50s or so, the protaganist's girlfriend has a lily growing in her lungs. He was french, lived in the US for a while, wrote those semi-sardonic / semi admiring type books about what he saw; all in the most surreal and abstract humour.

Take a look at this
#28 posted by Anonymous, April 18, 2009 10:10 AM


Did nobody catch the TERRIBLE puns? "Doctors were stumped," "the root of this mystery," etc.

Where have you gone Yakov Smirnoff?

Take a look at this

That lump of tissue appears to be resting on some gauze, out of the body. Did they removed half his lung together with the embedded fir?

Take a look at this
#30 posted by Anonymous, April 18, 2009 4:32 PM

whatch what you eat there could be a seed.

Take a look at this

Been wandering when this would pop up here... seemed inevitable and very boingboingish when I saw it on my local news.

It just made me think of the X-Files, and the black oil episodes (Tunguska?). Not natural, and clearly the result of some sort of human / plant hybrid experiments accidently released from the lab.

Now i'm off to get a tinfoil hat and a facemask.

Take a look at this
#33 posted by Anonymous, April 21, 2009 9:04 AM

Wait, I've been growing a pine tree for the last five years and mine doesn't look that good!

Take a look at this
#34 posted by Anonymous, May 29, 2009 2:39 PM

im scared to eat anything with seeds now

Leave a comment

Name:
Anonymous