Ugh. I wanted to find that cute and appealling, but I guess it's never to early to instill and encourage the dislike and trivialization of women in the computer industry. "How are you, pretty lady?" and "eww, eww, eww" really made me disappointed for that little boy.
"How are you, pretty lady?" and "eww, eww, eww" really made me disappointed for that little boy.
The "eww, eww, eww" struck me as the typical "girls have cooties" reaction for a kid his age. There's a good chance you'd get a similar reaction from a girl to pictures of men in a book that mostly had pictures of women.
The one I found troubling was "I'm talking to someone's wife." Poor kid can't conceptualize a woman as an employee, even a secretary. She's just "someone's wife." Not that the book is really helping him out there. I suppose it's too much to hope that a parent has told him that one of the reasons this book is silly and fun to mock is that it makes it seem like women are only good at looking pretty and can't be good at computers.
In 30 Years boingbong will be the refrigerator with the grand kids drawings on it.
This is boingboing. Inspired by boingboing.
The way that children learn humor through reverse engineering, mimicry of form with out understanding the underlying principals of funny is a rich topic for exploration.
Kittens was cute, but I thought this was kind of boring. The whole thing that makes it cute is the originality of the things kids say. This sounded like a bunch of failblog commenters talking through a six year old.
This video was made as a spoof of the kittens video which has been enjoyed and quoted for days around our house since we watched it. My son and I were having fun and did not intend to offend anyone, especially not any woman in the computer industry as my wife, his mother is one.
This video really needed some spoilers. The woman talking to the child during the video led me to the same thoughts as comment 19. Kids being genuine and personal about a project that they were inspired to do on their own is funny, cute, and enjoyable. Parents putting words into the mouth of a child that doesn't understand what he is saying is brutal to watch. Speaking of things that are brutal to watch, this was vaguely reminiscent of some American Idol auditions and performances. Kids should live along with their (the kid's) dreams and their parents should support them, but not invade their personality, just encourage that personality to come out.
I don't think this is a "spoof" as it did not mock the original work.
I was going comment that this FAILs b/c kid was obviously coached . But I remember when Will Farrel coached a 2-yr old to swear as a landlady and that was funny. So coaching has nothing to do with it.
I think the problem is that we expect it to be either funny or cute or both. It cannot be cute , b/c cute things are genuine . The coaching makes it not cute. It's also not funny b/c humor requires something unexpected. But much of this stuff about computers are expected.
Oh no. I've been waiting a month and a half for 2009's meme. Please tell me it's not "Videos of kids showing unfunny books while saying unfunny things written by their parents."
Whoa, what's with all the meme-hate today? This wasn't cute like the little girl one, but I thought it was pretty funny. I find this particular meme pretty fascinating, it's a step up in depth from the lolcat. This is a creative medium that's not limited to humor or cuteness. It's a form of poetry.
firstly, i actually thought this was funnier than the kittens one. and i love kittens.
secondly, was that ray walston from my favorite martian talking to "someone's wife"??
and thirdly, the new dr. who is NOT crappy. and i have been watching them since the mid 1970s. before this latest reboot, i was a die-hard tom baker fan.
Elements of what the child is saying (whether coached or not) concern me as a parent ...
Basic research shows that this was sent to Boing Boing by the maker of video ...
Can only assume is was made by father using child ...
In an attempt to gain subscribers/viewers for his YouTube channel ...
Exploitation perhaps?? ...
And finally ...
A waste of page space on this site ...
As this video is not a wonderful thing.
aw come on guys, what is this, a YouTube comment thread? surely we can set the bar a little higher. maybe it wasn't the most "wonderful" thing i've ever seen, but it made me laugh a little, and that's gotta count for something.
Obviously a project of the boy and his parents. He came up with some lines, they helped him come up with others, they wrote some zingers of their own for him to deliver. So what? I have no problem with parents being creative with their kids. In fact, I have very fond memories of writing stories with my parents active participation. If we could have stuck those stories up on a bulletin board for the whole world to read, I would have begged for them to do it.
Hell, even if some parents did write every word in a skit and their kids acted it out for youtube, if the kids enjoy themselves I still wouldn't use "scripted" as a pejorative. Things kids do spontaneously don't have any greater value for me than those that they collaborate on with adults.
Is that Joanna Lumley leaning against the Computer Space Cabinet?
Which, incidently, "utilizes no microprocessor, RAM or ROM. The entire computer system is a state machine made of discrete 74 series TTL logic elements. Graphic elements are held in diode arrays".
What a horrible patronising child. I feel really sorry for the author of what at "I LIKES COMPUTERZ!" first glance seems to be a pretty interesting book. Get the shovel. When the cops ask, you've never seen the kid and I was with you all day.
nope.
I don't get it.
The sexism this child expresses about computers and women is impressive at such a young age. Hopefully someone will teach him otherwise.
lurvs it
Inspired by inspiration.
Fail.
Ugh. I wanted to find that cute and appealling, but I guess it's never to early to instill and encourage the dislike and trivialization of women in the computer industry. "How are you, pretty lady?" and "eww, eww, eww" really made me disappointed for that little boy.
FTW
This is what happens when you bring up kids on ICanHazCheezburger, without the actual understanding of what makes it funny (incorrect grammar and spelling). Soon enough this kid will be attempting to gain access to 13+ websites.
Loved the original; this one... not so much.
Why?
a) Felt forced and unnatural
b) Went for easy, obvious, cliched jokes
c) Lacked the charm and innocence of the original version
d) Sure seemed like it was written by an adult
All-in-all, a pale imitation of the original
(at least that's what my five-year-old daughter said).....
I chuckled.
Try to grow a sense of humor people.
@ #6: Two words: Lighten up. It's a little kid. Get a sense of humor.
@ #2: Ummm...what cave have you been hiding in for the last week? Get a clue.
Overall, this was a rather limp-wristed re-take on the "kittens" one, but seriously, people - take it for what it is and stop being so damned cynical!
Gretchen, stop trying to make fetch happen! It's not going to happen!
tvc - yeah I suspect they have not already noted the Kittens meme. In response to that, I think it was alright.
"How are you, pretty lady?" and "eww, eww, eww" really made me disappointed for that little boy.
The "eww, eww, eww" struck me as the typical "girls have cooties" reaction for a kid his age. There's a good chance you'd get a similar reaction from a girl to pictures of men in a book that mostly had pictures of women.
The one I found troubling was "I'm talking to someone's wife." Poor kid can't conceptualize a woman as an employee, even a secretary. She's just "someone's wife." Not that the book is really helping him out there. I suppose it's too much to hope that a parent has told him that one of the reasons this book is silly and fun to mock is that it makes it seem like women are only good at looking pretty and can't be good at computers.
@#8 i don't think the kid made up the dialogue. it seems 100% scripted by his folks to me.
Is this real life?
I feel funny.
Is this gonna be forever?
(Nuh-uh! Don't touch it!)
ehmm...can we just let this mildly entertaining meme die a natural death now?
i agree. scripted. not a wonderful thing.
In 30 Years boingbong will be the refrigerator with the grand kids drawings on it.
This is boingboing. Inspired by boingboing.
The way that children learn humor through reverse engineering, mimicry of form with out understanding the underlying principals of funny is a rich topic for exploration.
But not like this.
Cute and funny. Clues for the Clueless:
Kittens, inspired by Kittens!
kittens, inpired by David after the dentist
Kittens, inspired by Christian Bale
Parents:
STOP PUTTING WORDS IN YOUR CHILDREN'S MOUTHS.
Also:
OTHER PEOPLE DO NOT FIND YOUR CHILDREN AS CUTE AS YOU DO.
It seems like those two things can never be said enough.
he's no Christian Bale, that's for sure.
Escher's Hands?
Kittens was cute, but I thought this was kind of boring. The whole thing that makes it cute is the originality of the things kids say. This sounded like a bunch of failblog commenters talking through a six year old.
Yep, fail. Extremely unoriginal.
@19 - Correct. Other peoples kids are boring.
The scary thing is that I could name nearly all of the computers shown in the book!
@19 @23 - Yep, other peoples kids are especially un-cute when their parents are trying show them off as cute. Eww eww eww.
That book looks pretty awesome. I searched for "computers" in the books section on Amazon. Time to start going through the 677,724 results.
"Maths" stands for Mathematical Anti-Telharsic Harfatum Septomin.
@22 yep the kittens one was cute because it was funny AND it was the sort of things a kid would really make up.
Interracial dating! BOW WOW CHICKA WOW WOW!
but seriously, that made me lol a lil. IN MY MOUF!
...so you can drive while you drive
Comments, Inspired by Comments!
"I don't get it"
"Is this thing on?"
"Your momma's so fat...."
"Your sppelling stinks"
"I hate Cory!"
"Fail"
"^^ fail FAIL"
"Is this going to be forever?"
I love computers as much as I love kittens, but this one didn't do it for me as much as the original.
This video was made as a spoof of the kittens video which has been enjoyed and quoted for days around our house since we watched it. My son and I were having fun and did not intend to offend anyone, especially not any woman in the computer industry as my wife, his mother is one.
For those that are curious about the book it is named
Computers An Illustrated History by Christian Wurster.
BoringBoring.net
Now we just need to reference this back to David Choo's item about haters and the circle of life will be complete!
Brett, I hope you have your flame retardant suit on, and all your vowels in a safe place. The almighty hammer is swift around here.
23D, good spoof, but maybe a bit too soon. Or a bit too directed - you can hear your wife giving directions...IMO, that killed it.
This video really needed some spoilers. The woman talking to the child during the video led me to the same thoughts as comment 19. Kids being genuine and personal about a project that they were inspired to do on their own is funny, cute, and enjoyable. Parents putting words into the mouth of a child that doesn't understand what he is saying is brutal to watch. Speaking of things that are brutal to watch, this was vaguely reminiscent of some American Idol auditions and performances. Kids should live along with their (the kid's) dreams and their parents should support them, but not invade their personality, just encourage that personality to come out.
Definitely prefer the original
I don't think this is a "spoof" as it did not mock the original work.
I was going comment that this FAILs b/c kid was obviously coached . But I remember when Will Farrel coached a 2-yr old to swear as a landlady and that was funny. So coaching has nothing to do with it.
I think the problem is that we expect it to be either funny or cute or both. It cannot be cute , b/c cute things are genuine . The coaching makes it not cute. It's also not funny b/c humor requires something unexpected. But much of this stuff about computers are expected.
So FAIL.
Oh no. I've been waiting a month and a half for 2009's meme. Please tell me it's not "Videos of kids showing unfunny books while saying unfunny things written by their parents."
I could totally hear Harmony Korine telling Herzog what time it is in Julian Donkey Boy, too... Totally killed it for me.
Whoa, what's with all the meme-hate today? This wasn't cute like the little girl one, but I thought it was pretty funny. I find this particular meme pretty fascinating, it's a step up in depth from the lolcat. This is a creative medium that's not limited to humor or cuteness. It's a form of poetry.
@ #10: No you misunderstand my "I don't get it". I get the references, but I don't get why it's funny.
This comment thread reminds me of conversations with people who can't stand the old Dr. Who and thing the crappy new Dr. Who is pretty good.
my fav! part is the Bamb chick-a boww wow!!
Video, not so good. Video title, absolute genius.
STEPHEN:
The new Doctor Who IS crappy, isn't it? I absolutely don't understand why everyone likes it so bloody much.
Can't believe whatsisname Moffat is writing the Tintin film...
This kid was fed many of his lines. Meh.
Fail inspired by Fail..
firstly, i actually thought this was funnier than the kittens one. and i love kittens.
secondly, was that ray walston from my favorite martian talking to "someone's wife"??
and thirdly, the new dr. who is NOT crappy. and i have been watching them since the mid 1970s. before this latest reboot, i was a die-hard tom baker fan.
fourthly, there is no number four.
I get the references, but I don't get why it's funny.
At this point YOU are why it's funny.
I made your mom funny.
@33: A slight tweak to your list!
Comments, Inspired by Comments!
"I don't get it"
"Is this thing on?"
"Yr mmm's s ft...."
"Yr sppllng stnks"
" ht Cr!"
"Fail"
"^^ fail FAIL"
"Is this going to be forever?"
The Internet is going to collapse under the weight of its self-references. Getting to be like if Charlie Kaufman wrote sketches for House of Buggin'.
Not funny ...
Elements of what the child is saying (whether coached or not) concern me as a parent ...
Basic research shows that this was sent to Boing Boing by the maker of video ...
Can only assume is was made by father using child ...
In an attempt to gain subscribers/viewers for his YouTube channel ...
Exploitation perhaps?? ...
And finally ...
A waste of page space on this site ...
As this video is not a wonderful thing.
aw come on guys, what is this, a YouTube comment thread? surely we can set the bar a little higher. maybe it wasn't the most "wonderful" thing i've ever seen, but it made me laugh a little, and that's gotta count for something.
the only thing that makes this at all interesting is that it is evidence of the strong effect that the first kibk vid has.
kibk is a mysterious force. it shouldn't be sullied by hack imitators.
pepper and chips,
x
I wanted to hate it, but I still laughed.
I love all the serious analysis that's been written to defend opinions of fail. I look forward to graduate papers on the subject.
Made me laugh.
Obviously a project of the boy and his parents. He came up with some lines, they helped him come up with others, they wrote some zingers of their own for him to deliver. So what? I have no problem with parents being creative with their kids. In fact, I have very fond memories of writing stories with my parents active participation. If we could have stuck those stories up on a bulletin board for the whole world to read, I would have begged for them to do it.
Hell, even if some parents did write every word in a skit and their kids acted it out for youtube, if the kids enjoy themselves I still wouldn't use "scripted" as a pejorative. Things kids do spontaneously don't have any greater value for me than those that they collaborate on with adults.
MDH @33 FTW.
RIDL, I agree. Kids + parents playing around with a videocamera = win.
Computer Space Cabinet.
Was some kid talking and pointing at pictures around the photo of that sweet, sweet Computer Space Cabinet?
I enjoyed that SO much more than the kittens video - which I found annoying and precocious.
Is that Joanna Lumley leaning against the Computer Space Cabinet?
Which, incidently, "utilizes no microprocessor, RAM or ROM. The entire computer system is a state machine made of discrete 74 series TTL logic elements. Graphic elements are held in diode arrays".
Sweet.
What a horrible patronising child. I feel really sorry for the author of what at "I LIKES COMPUTERZ!" first glance seems to be a pretty interesting book. Get the shovel. When the cops ask, you've never seen the kid and I was with you all day.
Better than kittens, methinks.
Eh.
Written by adults.
Uninteresting, lacks spark.