Boing Boing: UK music industry execs can't talk straight about DRM

Wednesday, January 25, 2006

UK music industry execs can't talk straight about DRM

The BBC asked execs from the British Phonogram Institute (the UK's answer to RIAA), Napster, HMV, and IFPI (international RIAA) a series of questions about digital rights management technologies, which are used to restrict the freedoms of people who buy music instead of downloading it from unauthorized services. In general they spun their answers, avoided the hard questions, and reverted to talking points. Ewan Spence has done a masterful job of deconstructing their responses:

Question: Do you believe people who are buying CDs legally and copying that music to an iPod should be punished - as they are, in fact, breaking the law?
Peter Jamieson, BPI:
Consumers don't have the right to copy CDs in the UK and never have, and though we've never brought action against anyone for private copying, the advent of peer-to-peer and digital distribution has turned the issue on its head. (the average Ipod user has bought 20 tracks from ITMS. Where does Jamieson think the other gigabytes are coming from? Shall we sue them all? - Ewan)

Link (Thanks, Ewan!)

posted by Cory Doctorow at 01:14:32 PM permalink | Other blogs' comments

suggest a link \| defeat censorware \| rss \| archives \| t-shirts \| digital emporium \| podcast feed \| mark \| cory \| david \| xeni \| john
Support Bloggers' Rights! HOWTO: Get a link posted to Boing Boing Boing Boing Mobile powered by Winksite Fark rules! This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing with attribution. Boing Boing is a trademark of Happy Mutants LLC in the United States [and other countries]. Stats (About our stats) defeat censorware Policies Our first five years' worth of posts in one file	Wednesday, January 25, 2006 UK music industry execs can't talk straight about DRM The BBC asked execs from the British Phonogram Institute (the UK's answer to RIAA), Napster, HMV, and IFPI (international RIAA) a series of questions about digital rights management technologies, which are used to restrict the freedoms of people who buy music instead of downloading it from unauthorized services. In general they spun their answers, avoided the hard questions, and reverted to talking points. Ewan Spence has done a masterful job of deconstructing their responses: Question: Do you believe people who are buying CDs legally and copying that music to an iPod should be punished - as they are, in fact, breaking the law? Peter Jamieson, BPI: Consumers don't have the right to copy CDs in the UK and never have, and though we've never brought action against anyone for private copying, the advent of peer-to-peer and digital distribution has turned the issue on its head. (the average Ipod user has bought 20 tracks from ITMS. Where does Jamieson think the other gigabytes are coming from? Shall we sue them all? - Ewan) Link (Thanks, Ewan!) posted by Cory Doctorow at 01:14:32 PM permalink \| Other blogs' comments Email this entry to: Your email address: Message (optional):	Boing Boing Sponsored by: Your Text Ad Here Get BB by email: